| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Advances in Brief |
Institute of Environmental Studies [V. L. W., X. Y., B. T., K. R. W., J. P. W.] and Institute for Mutagenesis and the Department of Biological Sciences [V. L. W., X. Y., B. T., K. R. W., J. P. W., W. R. L.], Louisiana State University, Baton Rouge, Louisiana 70803, and The Childrens Hospital, Denver, Colorado 80516 [Q. W.]
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The background spontaneous mutation frequency appears to have a strong genetic component as opposed to environmental factors (3) . Under nonperturbating conditions, cells lacking any genome-destabilizing gene mutation would probably have a spontaneous DNA mutation frequency at a specific locus of less than one cell in a million, the presently accepted value of null gene mutations (4 , 5) . Thus, the frequency of DNA mutations is expected to be rare, on the order of less than one in a million cells in individuals who do not harbor an identified genetic disease associated with genomic stability and who have not been exposed to significant levels of genotoxic agents. However, in vivo data regarding spontaneous mutation frequencies for DNA base substitution and other point mutations not biased by null gene selection are lacking in the literature.
Using the Needle-in-a-Haystack mutation detection and identification PCR/RE3 /LCR technique (6) , we addressed the question of base substitution mutation frequencies in oncogenic loci in circulating PBLs in apparently normal individuals. Two of 19 individuals had a significantly higher frequency of oncogenic mutations in their PBLs. These data suggest that a substantial proportion of individuals within the human population may harbor a significant frequency of oncogenic mutations in circulating leukocytes.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Needle-in-a-Haystack PCR/RE/LCR Analysis.
PBL DNAs were assayed for base substitution mutations at sensitivities
of one in a million cells or better using the PCR/RE/LCR procedures
described by Wilson et al. (6)
. The PCR and LCR
primer designs and protocols for the majority of sites analyzed in this
work have been described previously by Wilson et al.
(6)
. The LCR primers for the second base of codon 12 of
the N-ras gene and the first base of codon 13 or the
N-ras gene are listed in Table 1
, as are the LCR oligonucleotide mutant template standards for the
Ha-ras and N-ras sites. The LCR primers and
template standards for the first base of codon 248 of p53 have been
described previously by Wilson et al. (6)
.
Human Ha-ras genomic sequence plasmids pbC-N1 and pT24-C3
were obtained from American Type Culture Collection and propagated in
Escherichia coli, as described previously (6)
.
All oligonucleotide primers and templates were obtained as custom
synthesis form BioServe Biotechnologies, Ltd. (Laurel, MD).
|
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
To approach this question of background base substitution mutation
frequency, human PBL DNAs were obtained from 19 phenotypically normal
volunteers. The age of these donors ranged from 2.546 years, and both
genders were almost equally represented. Four individuals did not
provide their age (date of birth), and another 4 of the 19 specimens
were obtained anonymously (Table 2)
.
|
Codon 12 of the Ha-ras gene was the first locus to be
analyzed. Each duplicate or triplicate sample containing 6 µg of PBL
specimen DNA was analyzed by PCR/RE/LCR procedures. A G
T
transversion mutation was observed in specimen 93014 (Fig. 1
). A standard mix of 10-6 mutant (pT24-C3) to
wild-type plasmid DNA mix was included in the PCR/RE selection and LCR
analyses to ensure the sensitivity of the assay. The shadow observed
above the bands in Fig. 1
does not represent additional mutations
because no mutations were observed in specimens when the LCR reactions
contained only the mutant A primers, whereas LCR bands were observed
for the oligonucleotide template standard for mutant A (data not
shown). The 1 pmol/µl concentration of oligonucleotide template
standard mutant C was saturating because only a single 48-bp band
representing the antisense LCR primer set was observed. Lower
concentrations of oligonucleotide standards enable the display of both
LCR product bands (as noted below).
|
10-6 (Table 2)
A and G
C mutations were
assayed simultaneously with the G
T mutation, only G
T mutations
were observed in two specimens at this locus (Fig. 1
The number of individual specimens displaying detectable rare base
substitution mutations increased slightly at the p53 codon
248 locus, amounting to 4 of 18 specimens analyzed (Table 2)
. All of
these specimens were assayed for p53 codon 248 mutations in
triplicate. Specimens 890061, 93008, and 93014 provided detectable
C
T transition mutations, whereas specimen 890062 harbored both C
T
transition and C
A transversion mutations (data not shown). The
triplicate analysis of these samples demonstrated a roughly 10-fold
variation in density of the resultant LCR mutant product bands, clearly
demonstrating that quantitation of mutant frequency by densitometry
would be inaccurate (data not shown). The sensitivity of the PCR/RE/LCR
assay is adjustable, so that quantitation of these rare mutants
was further attempted with the analysis of both the restricted PCR
products from the second and third PCR/RE selection cycles. By reducing
the number of PCR/RE selection cycles used, the PCR/RE/LCR assay
becomes less sensitive. Specimen 890062 appears to harbor
p53 codon 248 mutant cells at a frequency of less than 1 in
105 (data not shown). More accurate quantitation
of the proportion of mutant cells within these PBL DNAs by the analysis
of smaller and smaller aliquots of DNA (representing smaller and
smaller numbers of cells) was not undertaken due to the limited
quantities of DNA available for these cases.
Because these mutation analyses were focused on circulating blood
cells, and the ras gene most commonly associated with
leukemias and lymphomas is the N-ras gene, the determination
of rare cells harboring mutations in the N-ras gene would be
significant. A G
T transversion mutation in the first base of codon
12 of the N-ras gene was also detectable at the frequency of
10-6 circulating leukocytes in specimens
890048, 890061, and 93014 (Table 2
; see Ref. 6
for
representative LCR example).
Transversion mutations were also common at the second base of codon 12
of the N-ras gene in these PBL DNA specimens, as shown for
specimens 890048 and 93018 (Fig. 2A
). Half of the 12 specimens assayed at this site provided
detectable G
T mutations (Table 2)
.
|
A mutation that appears to be a
relatively rare non-CpG site transition mutation involving guanosine
residue in these oncogenic loci.
Of the 12 individuals assayed for three or more base sites, two
stand out with detectable mutations at multiple sites (Table 2)
.
Specimens 890061 and 93014 displayed mutations in four of five sites
and four of four sites, respectively, which was significantly different
from the other individuals (
2 = 35,
P < 0.01 for 17 mutations from all 19
individuals;
2 = 22,
P < 0.02 for 14 mutations from only the12
individuals tested at three or more base sites).
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2 = 22; P < 0.02). Although isolated and significant genotoxic exposures cannot be entirely ruled out, the data suggest that these two individuals display a hypermutable phenotype. That is, they may harbor one or more hypermutable leukocyte clones or a constitutional predisposition to mutations. Individual AB was reported by Albertini et al. (1) to harbor a hypermutable T-lymphocyte clone detectable by culture selection of T-cell receptor gene rearrangements and HPRT mutation analyses. If hypermutability is due to a germ-line error, the characteristics of an individuals phenotype vary according to the constitutional error, being dependent on the location, type of mutation, and gene involved (8, 9, 10, 11) . Alternatively, these two individuals could be displaying a "transient mutator phenotype" in selected stem cells such that these multiple loci PCR/RE/LCR analyses of a PBL specimen obtained at a later date might be negative for hypermutability (12 , 13) . Thus, the frequency of some form of hypermutable phenotype within the human population may be on the order of 1 in 10.
Discounting the two hypermutable individuals, the overall background base substitution mutation frequency in PBL specimens appears to be less than one in a million circulating cells. Only eight samples were found mutant at one cell or more in a million wild-type cells of 57 separate base site analyses (ignoring the data of the two hypermutable individuals). This is in agreement with the frequency of HPRT null gene mutations determined in circulating lymphocytes (4 , 5) . Limited quantities of DNA restricted the determination of the frequency of mutant cells within individual PBL specimens at each of the base sites studied.
Only missense mutations were assayed in this study. None of the base sites studied were capable of producing a nonsense mutation, and deletions and insertions would not be detected with the LCR designs used in this study. Altogether, 17 independent mutations were detected and identified in the 66 base site-individuals assayed. The frequency of individual PBL specimens containing rare mutations varied from loci to loci and by base site within the same loci (N-ras codons 12 and 13). Only 2 of 17 PBL DNAs (12%) were found to contain rare Ha-ras mutant cells, whereas 4 of 18 specimens (22%) contained p53 codon 248 mutant cells. The higher mutant incidence of the latter probably represents the increased mutability of a known methylated CpG site (14, 15, 16) . The second base of codon 12 of N-ras produced the highest mutation incidence within the individual PBL specimens because 50% of the DNAs analyzed contained rare mutant cells. The higher mutation frequency of the N-ras gene over the Ha-ras gene in PBL specimens may be a tissue-specific phenomenon because these data are in accordance with the fact that the N-ras gene is generally more often associated with leukemias and lymphomas (17) . The second base in codon 12 of the N-ras gene has been reported to be mutated more commonly than the first base (17) .
Four of the five mutations identified at the p53 codon 248
locus were C
T transitions. These data support the literature
regarding the incidence of deamination of 5-methyldeoxycytidine
residues in DNA (14, 15, 16)
. The first base of codon 248
represents a CpG site that is known to be commonly methylated in most,
if not all, tissues (14)
. The incidence of CpG to TpG
mutations is overrepresented in the known genetic disease, causing
mutations in the human population and providing more than 30% of all
of the disease-associated mutations in reported germ-line and somatic
abnormalities (14, 15, 16)
. The rate of deamination of
5-methyldeoxycytidine has been reported to be high enough to account
for this incidence of CpG
TpG transition mutations, especially if the
fidelity of repair of G:T mispairs is less than the repair of G:U
mispairs (15)
.
Aside from the one G
A mutation in the first base of codon 13
of the N-ras gene, all of the other independent
Ha-ras and N-ras mutations observed in these PBL
DNAs were G
T transversions. The one C
A transversion at the CpG
site probably represents a G
T mutation in the complementary strand
(18
, 19)
. Although the majority of sites assayed are in
the ras proto-oncogenes, these data are in agreement with
the high nontranscribed strand bias for G
T transversion mutations in
p53 (20)
. G
T transversions also appear to
represent the majority of activation mutations in the human
ras genes (21)
.
These mutations are most likely not artifacts of the PCR/RE/LCR assay.
The major deoxyguanosine mutation induced by Taq polymerase is a G
A
transition, with G
T transversion mutations being the least common
error (22
, 23)
. The second and third cycle of PCR and
restriction enzyme (PCR/RE) selection use Pfu or Pfu
Turbo polymerases, which have a higher fidelity, but produce G
T
transition mutations (24
, 25)
. However, the detection of
an artifact-induced mutation during the second or third cycle of PCR/RE
selection (after the initial 25 cycles of PCR in the first cycle of
PCR/RE selection) is very unlikely in this assay (6)
.
Also, analyses were run in duplicate and in triplicate in selective
cases, and no discrepancies were found in the detection and
identification of mutations between replicates.
DNA damage such as 8-hydroxydeoxyguanosine could cause mispairing
during the initial PCR amplifications because this base adduct also
hydrogen bonds with deoxyadenosine, and oxidative damage has been
reported to occur during standard DNA isolation procedures
(26)
. However, 8-hydroxydeoxyguanosine would have to occur
consistently in the same base site at a high enough frequency to enable
the replicate detection of mutations in a given specimen while not
occurring significantly at this same site in other specimens. It is
more likely that in vivo oxidative damage has given rise to
these G
T transversion mutations before DNA isolation
(26)
. However, transversions are also associated with
exposure to tobacco smoke, aflatoxin, and other environmental
carcinogens (5
, 11
, 27
, 28) .
In summary, the procedure of PCR/RE/LCR detection and identification of rare mutant cells at multiple loci has the potential to identify individuals who may be hypermutable in response to environmental insults, both endogenous and exogenous. The spectrum of base substitution mutations identified within groups of individuals who may be exposed to specific genotoxic agents will be valuable in the clarification of the agent or agents involved in the etiology of disease (11) . Additionally, these techniques are not limited to peripheral blood specimens, but they do require significant quantities of DNA. Additional studies, including a more elaborate and well-designed epidemiological study of a larger number of people, will be required to characterize the potential of this approach. Discerning the in vivo dynamics of mutation frequencies per locus per cell division in a chosen tissue will require the study of multiple samples from an individual over time.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
1 Supported in part by NIH Grant R21CA69650 from
the National Cancer Institute and by research fellowship awards by the
Howard Hughes Undergraduate Biological Science Educational Program (to
K. R. W. and J. P. W.). ![]()
2 To whom requests for reprints should be
addressed, at Institute of Environmental Studies, 42 Atkinson Hall,
Louisiana State University, Baton Rouge, LA 70803. Phone: (225)
388-1753 or (225) 388-8876; Fax: (225) 388-4286; E-mail: Monster77{at}aol.com ![]()
3 The abbreviations used are: RE, restriction
endonuclease digestion; LCR, ligase chain reaction; PBL, peripheral
blood leukocyte. ![]()
Received 9/22/99. Accepted 2/17/00.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
D. T. Bowen, M. E. Frew, R. Hills, R. E. Gale, K. Wheatley, M. J. Groves, S. E. Langabeer, P. D. Kottaridis, A. V. Moorman, A. K. Burnett, et al. RAS mutation in acute myeloid leukemia is associated with distinct cytogenetic subgroups but does not influence outcome in patients younger than 60 years Blood, September 15, 2005; 106(6): 2113 - 2119. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. S. Kim and W. G. Thilly Ligation of high-melting-temperature 'clamp' sequence extends the scanning range of rare point-mutational analysis by constant denaturant capillary electrophoresis (CDCE) to most of the human genome Nucleic Acids Res., August 15, 2003; 31(16): e97 - e97. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. Kaur and G. M. Makrigiorgos Novel amplification of DNA in a hairpin structure: towards a radical elimination of PCR errors from amplified DNA Nucleic Acids Res., March 15, 2003; 31(6): e26 - e26. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| Cancer Research | Clinical Cancer Research |
| Cancer Epidemiology Biomarkers & Prevention | Molecular Cancer Therapeutics |
| Molecular Cancer Research | Cancer Prevention Research |
| Cancer Prevention Journals Portal | Cancer Reviews Online |
| Annual Meeting Education Book | Meeting Abstracts Online |