Previous research on the vasculature of tumor-bearing animals has focused upon the microvasculature. Magnetic resonance angiography (MRA) offers a noninvasive, complementary approach that provides information about larger vessels. Quantitative analysis of MRA images of spontaneous preclinical tumor models has not been previously reported. Eleven TgT121;p53+/− mice, which invariably develop choroid plexus carcinoma (CPC), and nine age-matched healthy controls were imaged using T1, T2, and a high-resolution three-dimensional time-of-flight MRA sequences at 3 T. Tumors and vessels were segmented to determine tumor volume and vascular attributes, including number of terminal branches, vessel count, and the average vessel radii of MRA-visible vessels within the tumor. Differences in the vasculature between tumor-bearing animals and healthy controls were analyzed statistically. Although the spatial resolution of MRA prohibits visualization of capillaries, a high density of intratumor blood vessels was visualized in CPC mice. A significant increase in terminal branch count and vessel count, but not average vessel radius, was observed in CPCs when compared with normal controls. Both terminal branch count and vessel count were highly correlated with tumor volume. This study represents the first MRA analysis of a spontaneous preclinical brain tumor model. Although the spatial resolution of MRA is less than histologic analysis, MRA-obtained vascular attributes provide useful information with full brain coverage. We show that consistent tumor vasculature properties can be determined by MRA. Such methods are critical for developing preclinical therapeutic testing and will help guide the development of human brain tumor analyses.
- Choroid plexus
- Genetically engineered mice
- Brain tumor
A critical stage in the development of aggressive cancers is the establishment of a blood supply. Much research has been devoted to understanding this process using preclinical models that involve cell line transplantation, such as xenografts. Furthermore, numerous clinical trials have been initiated to test the efficacy of angiogenesis inhibitors with limited success despite promising preclinical xenograft data ( 1, 2). In recent years, several mouse models of cancer have been established that develop tumors de novo based on genetic events engineered into the mouse, and, in several cases, the transition to angiogenesis has been established ( 3– 11). These models provide an opportunity to develop methods for in vivo imaging to characterize the properties of tumor vasculature and to develop sensitive strategies for preclinical testing.
Previous efforts to characterize tumor vasculature in mouse brain tumor models relied on sacrificing the animals, thus prohibiting longitudinal studies of angiogenesis. Extensive efforts have been devoted to the development of approaches capable of revealing the unique features associated with tumor neoangiogenesis in vivo. Specifically, noninvasive approaches, such as dynamic susceptibility contrast magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), have been utilized to depict regional vascular density, potentially useful in differentiating lesion pathology ( 12– 19). In addition, the continual monitoring of magnetic resonance signal changes postcontrast can provide consistent vascular permeability measurements in animal and human subjects ( 19, 20). Both magnetic resonance approaches offer insight into the microscopic physiologic alterations associated with tumor vasculature. However, little attention has been given to macroscopic vessels within these tumors.
High-resolution magnetic resonance angiography (MRA) offers a macroscopic view of the entire tumor vasculature. These parameters are likely to be of physiologic importance by complementing magnetic resonance perfusion and permeability studies. Indeed, in a recent blinded study of human tumor patients whose images were analyzed before lesion resection, a statistical analysis of the shapes of MRA-extracted blood vessels proved successful in separating benign from malignant disease in all cases ( 21).
The purposes of the current study are to determine whether tumor-associated vasculature can be visualized and extracted from the MRA images of tumor-bearing mice and, if so, to assess the properties quantitatively by which they differ from normal mice. The tumor model used is a well-characterized, genetically engineered mouse model in which choroid plexus carcinoma (CPC) develops with 100% penetrance ( 6, 7). The histologic characteristics of these tumors have also been well studied ( 6, 7) and mature tumors always exhibit marked angiogenesis.
This report describes the acquisition of high-resolution magnetic resonance images, the extraction of blood vessels, the definition of tumors from the images of tumor-bearing animals, and the registration of images into a common coordinate system. For each tumor, we then statistically compare the number of terminal branches, the vessel count, and the average vessel radius to the means and SDs of the vasculature within the same anatomic region of the healthy controls. We conclude that tumor-associated vasculature can indeed be visualized and extracted successfully from the images of CPC-bearing mice.
Materials and Methods
Choroid plexus carcinoma mouse model. TgT121;p53+/− mice develop focally aggressive angiogenic CPC that is histologically detectable by 8 weeks and terminal by 12 weeks of age ( 7, 22). Often, a single animal develops multiple focal tumors. Tumors are initiated by choroid plexus–specific expression of T121, an NH2-terminal fragment of SV40 large T antigen that binds and inactivates the tumor suppressor pRb and related proteins p107 and p130 ( 22). T121 induces cell proliferation and p53-dependent apoptosis throughout the choroid plexus epithelium such that heterozygosity for a p53 null allele facilitates multifocal tumor progression to CPC with complete p53 loss. Histologic analyses show that the timing and penetrance of tumor development is highly reproducible ( 6). CPC tumors are heavily vascular lesions and thus provide an ideal tumor type in which to study the effect of antiangiogenic agents in experimental animals.
A total of 20 mice were studied, including 11 TgT121;p53+/− mice and nine age-matched control mice. Of the TgT121;p53+/− animals, nine were terminal (10-11 weeks of age), whereas two were subterminal (8-9 weeks of age). All animal protocols were approved by the Institutional Care for Animal Use Committee.
Magnetic resonance imaging. All images were acquired on a Siemens 3T Allegra head only scanner (Siemens Medical, Inc., Erlangen, Germany) with a maximum gradient strength of 40 mT/m and a slew rate of 400 mT/m/ms. A custom-made volume coil measuring 2.1 cm in diameter was utilized. Imaging sequences included a precontrast two-dimensional multislice T1-weighted sequence (30 mm2 field of view; 0.1 × 0.1 × 1.0 mm3 voxel size; repetition time, 500 milliseconds; echo time, 13 milliseconds; four averages; and acquisition time 8:46) and a two-dimensional multislice T2-weighted sequence (30 mm2 field of view; 0.1 × 0.1 × 1.0 mm3 voxel size; repetition time, 6,990 milliseconds; echo time, 100 milliseconds; four averages; and acquisition time, 11:20). A high-resolution three-dimensional time-of-flight MRA sequence was used for acquiring MRA images (30 mm2 field of view; 0.1 × 0.1 × 0.1 mm3 voxel size; repetition time, 53 milliseconds; echo time, 8.8 milliseconds; two averages; 256 × 256 resolution; and acquisition time, 23:11). All of the above imaging sequences were applied before the injection of a magnetic resonance contrast agent (Gd-diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid) Following an i.p. injection of 0.5 mL gadolinium contrast agent, postcontrast T1-weighted images were acquired with identical parameters as above. Total acquisition time was ∼1 hour.
Isoflurane, an inhalant anesthesia, was mixed with air and administered to animals at 2% induction and 1% maintenance through a nose cone. All mice were stereotactically immobilized before imaging.
Data analysis. All images were transferred to a personal computer for postprocessing. Data analysis included vascular segmentation, lesion segmentation, image registration, derivation of vascular attributes, and statistical analysis.
Vessels were extracted from MRA images using a semiautomated, multiscale method that proceeds from user-supplied seed points to automatically define the path of each vessel and to calculate the radius at each vessel point. Detailed descriptions of the vascular segmentation approaches are described in reference ( 23). In short, the method models a vessel in three steps: (a) definition of a seed point on or near a vessel of interest; (b) automatic, dynamic-scale extraction of an image intensity ridge representing the central skeleton of the vessel; and (c) automatic determination of vessel radius at each centerline point. The output of the program defines each vessel as an ordered set of x, y, z points, indicating the spatial position of the centerline of that vessel with an associated radius at each point. For this report, we use the term “vessel” to indicate a single, unbranching structure. A single vessel might have one or more child branches, but the analyses described here count each child branch as an independent vessel.
Tumors were extracted from gadolinium-enhanced T1-weighted images using a partially manual program that defines tumors via polygon drawing and filling on orthogonal cuts through an image volume ( 24).
All images were then registered via a normalized mutual-information based, affine registration into the coordinate system of one of the healthy mouse MRA studies ( 25). Using a combination of forward and backward mapping, the same region of interest (the tumor boundary) could thus be mapped into the undeformed space of the MRA of any animal. Registration of tumor-bearing mice into the healthy coordinate system was often difficult as mice with large tumors possessed markedly bulging skulls without deformation of the jaw. In such cases, the brain was segmented and registration was done upon the brain alone.
For each tumor, the surface was mapped into the MRA of tumor mouse and vessels were clipped to the tumor surface. Vascular attributes, as described below, were derived for the vessel segments contained by the region of interest (the volume defined by the tumor surface). This same region of interest was then mapped into the coordinate space of each healthy mouse and the same vascular attributes were derived for each normal mouse. Note that although some vessels traversed the region of interest, analysis was only done upon the vessel segments contained within the defined tumor region.
This article considers three vessel attributes. The average vessel radius was calculated by summing the radius at each centerline point and dividing by the number of vessel points. The vessel count was the number of vessels (including clipped vessels) within the confines of the tumor. Each branch counted as one vessel. The terminal branch count was defined as the vessels lying entirely within the tumor (the terminal branches originate and end within the region of interest and no point in a terminal vessel branch lies outside the region). Hypervascular tumors induce the formation of new vessels within the tumor confines, and the terminal branch count, therefore, provides an indirect measure of vessel sprouting. Figure 1 shows a region of interest (oval) and two vessels (thick lines) that traverse it. Three terminal branches are shown as narrow lines. The total vessel count would be five in this example. Traversing, entering, or exiting vessels are clipped to the tumor surface and analysis is done only on the vessel segments lying within the confines of the region of interest. Finally, tumor volumes were calculated automatically by summing the number of voxels within the tumor and multiplying by the voxel size.
Statistical analysis. To compare how vascular attributes differed between CPC and normal brain, we calculated the mean and SD for each of the vascular attributes over the same anatomic location as each tumor in the nine normal mice, allowing for the calculation of Z-scores for each vascular attribute. In addition, linear regression analysis was utilized to determine the relation between average vessel radius, vessel count, terminal branch count, and lesion volume.
Eleven TgT121;p53+/− animals possessed a total of 15 tumors, each of which was analyzed independently. Three (mice 01, 05, and 06; Table 1 ) of the nine terminal mice (mice 00-09; Table 1) had more than one lesion. Gadolinium-enhanced images were not available or were of low quality in two animals; in these cases, T2 images were used to define tumor margins.
The three-dimensional time-of-flight MRA images generated consistent high-resolution images of all mice in the study. Figure 2 provides an example of T1 ( Fig. 2A), T2 ( Fig. 2B), and MRA ( Fig. 2C) and of the vessel trees ( Fig. 2D) defined from a healthy mouse. Vessel trees are color coded by circulatory group in this figure. Note that although the limits of MRA resolution preclude direct imaging of capillary beds, each of the major circulatory groups contains significant vascular detail.
Figure 3 provides an example of a subterminal mouse (mouse 07; Table 1) possessing multiple tiny tumors within a dilated ventricular system ( Fig. 3A, arrow). In this case, the tumors were so multitudinous and small that no attempt was made to define the tumors individually, but the entire ventricular system was defined as a single region of interest for the later analysis of the vascular attributes.
The nine terminal mice each had one or more large tumors measuring ∼4 mm in diameter, and located in the third, fourth, and/or lateral ventricles. These larger tumors enhanced with gadolinium and were readily defined from contrast-enhanced T1 images. Figure 4 illustrates an example of a large tumor together with an associated histopathologic slice. Note that small tumor nodules, <1 mm3 in volume, can be seen on both the magnetic resonance slice images and on the associated histopathologic slice.
Results for average vessel radius, vessel count, terminal branch count, and tumor volume for each tumor are summarized in Table 1. This table also provides the Z-score values for average vessel radius, vessel count, and terminal branch count when compared with the age-matched normal controls at the same anatomic regions of the tumors. With the exception of a single very small mass (mouse 05; tumor 7), tumors displayed an increase in terminal branch count and vessel count compared with the matched anatomic region of control mice. This finding is consistent with the known hypervascularity associated with this particular tumor type. A lack of consistent regional difference in average vessel radius is observed between tumor and healthy vessels, probably because tumor-associated neoangiogenesis produces an increase in vessels of a variety of sizes.
The interplay between lesion volume, terminal branch count, and vessel count are shown in Fig. 5 , as compared between lesion volume and terminal branch count ( Fig. 5A), lesion volume, and vessel count ( Fig. 5B), and vessel count and terminal branch count ( Fig. 5C). A linear relationship exists between these three physiologic parameters.
Many evaluations of tumor angiogenesis using MRI have focused on the utilization of perfusion imaging for estimating vascular density, with encouraging results reported by several groups ( 13– 17). Although still under investigation, dynamic contrast imaging may provide a promising approach as reported in both patient and animal studies ( 13– 17). However, disadvantages of perfusion imaging include confusion due to breakdown of the blood-brain barrier and omission of small foci of malignancy resulting from low spatial resolution.
This report takes an alternative, but complementary approach by describing visualization of the larger vessels directly discernable from MRA to investigate the feasibility of imaging murine tumors and vessels. As shown in Figs. 3 and 4, abnormal vessels are clearly visible in both subterminal and terminal mice, suggesting that MRA may provide a reasonable means to monitor the progression of tumor angiogenesis in a preclinical tumor model.
As compared with healthy controls, a significant increase of terminal branch count and vessel count was observed in CPC mice, which is in good agreement with previously described histologic findings in this animal model ( 6). Intuitively, one would expect a correlation between terminal branch count and vessel count because an increase in terminal branch count will automatically produce an increase in vessel count. The terminal branch count provides a count of short vessels contained entirely within a region of interest. Tumor-associated neoangiogenesis is likely to produce a statistically significant increase in terminal branch count within a region of interest, because the tumor induces growth of new vessels within the tumor. Although an increase in terminal branch count will also produce an increase in the total vessel count, the total vessel count is likely to be variable when a region of interest is mapped between a tumor subject and multiple healthy subjects because the mass effect of a tumor may displace vessels that would normally course within the region of interest. The two parameters, terminal branch count and vessel count, are therefore related, but terminal branch count is likely to provide a more reliable measure of tumor neoangiogenesis. In contrast, no significant differences were found in average vessel radius between healthy animals and the tumor group, most likely due to tumor neoangiogenesis involving both large and small vessels ( 26). Both terminal branch count and vessel count were linearly correlated with the lesion volume. This finding is in agreement with previous reports that describe homogeneity of this tumor as seen by histologic section ( 6).
Our study is important for several reasons. First, to our knowledge, this report represents the first in vivo assessment of tumor vasculature based on MRA visible vessels in a well-controlled genetic mouse brain tumor model. Second, all images were coregistered into a common coordinate system so that a direct comparison of the vasculature between CPC mice and normal controls at similar anatomic locations can be obtained. This ability is of importance because vessel distribution and shape is not uniform throughout the brain. Such registration will likely be helpful to follow tumor progression or response to treatment in individual animals over time.
Third, the vascular segmentation and analysis methods described provide automated, quantitative measures of vessel shape and density with statistical comparison to a database of healthy controls. Although the spatial resolution of magnetic resonance images is not as high as that of histology, the quantitative parameters offered by our approach allow direct assessment of vascular morphology with coverage of the entire head in a noninvasive fashion.
Finally, tumor volume is calculated automatically. This ability is not only likely to prove helpful when following animals over time, but is clearly useful in enabling a direct comparison between several vascular attributes and lesion volume. Nevertheless, only postcontrast T1-weighted images were used to define tumor margins. It is possible that combination of T1-weighted and T2-weighted images, particularly FLAIR sequences, may further improve our ability to accurately define the margin of tumors although this is beyond the scope of our current study.
Although a spatial resolution of 0.1 mm3 was achieved, capillaries cannot be visualized by magnetic resonance and the experimentally derived vascular morphologic parameters are only applicable for MRA visible vessels. The smallest vessels we were able to define had a diameter of 0.1 mm3, as is compatible with the voxel size of the images acquired.
The method of registration used was both affine and tissue based and may not be the optimal method of aligning images when the purpose is to compare vasculature between individuals. A deformable, vessel-based registration method would be preferable. Others in our group are currently developing such an approach ( 22).
Future studies will focus on the following areas. First, as mentioned previously, many studies have focused on vascular density as measured by perfusion imaging. It would be of interest to compare vessel density measurements by perfusion imaging to the vessel density of the larger vessels imaged here. We have not done perfusion imaging in this study because severe leakage of the blood-brain barrier may confound estimates of vascular density. Nevertheless, an intravascular contrast agent such as AIM227 could potentially overcome this difficulty and provide an accurate estimate of vascular density. This study is currently in progress.
Second, the approach described in this report is applicable to longitudinal, noninvasive studies of individual animals. The ability to follow animals over time and to assess the vessel changes associated with malignancy in a noninvasive fashion will be of significant value to all investigators exploring the development and treatment of animal tumor models that closely mimic human tumors.
Finally, unlike perfusion imaging, which measures only vessel density, the definition of individual vessels from high-resolution MRA allows quantitative assessment of multiple measures of vessel shape. Several of these vessel attributes may be useful in the evaluation of disease ( 23, 27– 29). The ability to define mouse tumor vessels individually as described in this report will facilitate larger studies that can evaluate tumor neoangiogenesis not only on the basis of vessel density but also with the incorporation of other vessel attribute measures.
In summary, this report describes a set of methods useful for imaging brain tumors and, more uniquely, brain vasculature in the mouse. We describe results obtained in 9 healthy and 11 tumor-bearing animals, and conclude that high-resolution images can be obtained using a 3 T scanner within a reasonable time frame. In addition, the ability to segment vessels and brain tumors allows a direct analysis of the vasculature in relation to the brain tumors in living animals. The ability to conduct repeated studies using MRA offers a valuable tool for directly monitoring the effectiveness of different antiangiogenic therapies without sacrificing animals.
Grant support: R01 EB000219 NIH-National Institute for Biomedical Imaging and Bioengineering, U01 CA84314, S10 RR017212, and P30-CA-16086.
The costs of publication of this article were defrayed in part by the payment of page charges. This article must therefore be hereby marked advertisement in accordance with 18 U.S.C. Section 1734 solely to indicate this fact.
- Received December 6, 2004.
- Revision received June 28, 2005.
- Accepted July 7, 2005.
- ©2005 American Association for Cancer Research.